Ecom Outpost — Discover more storesJournalFor merchants

Product Research Scorecard

Rate up to four product ideas on the things that decide whether a product works for a small store. Weight what matters to you, and the scorecard ranks them. It uses only your ratings, so it's as good as your research.

FreeNo accountRuns in your browserNothing uploaded

Your ideas

Your product ideas
Idea 1
Idea 2 optional
Idea 3 optional
Idea 4 optional

Price and cost are only used to score margin. Use the same currency for both.

Score each idea from 1 (poor) to 5 (great)
CriterionWeightIdea 1Idea 2Idea 3Idea 4
Profit marginScored from your price and cost if you enter them, or score it yourself.
Evidence of demandFrom your own research: searches, sales of similar products, customer requests.
Room to compete5 = few strong sellers or a clear way to stand out.
Reliable supplierSamples, lead times, communication and quality.
Low return and compliance risk5 = rarely returned, no special rules, certifications or claims.
Easy to shipSmall, light, not fragile, no hazardous materials.
Repeat purchase potentialConsumables and refills score higher.
Fits your store and audienceWould your existing customers want it?
Sells year-round5 = steady all year, 1 = a short season.

Weight 5 means very important; 0 leaves the criterion out. Leave a score blank if you don't know yet: it's left out rather than counted as zero. "Auto" scores margin from the price and cost above.

The example uses made-up products and ratings.

How it works

Each idea's score is the weighted average of the ratings you give it, shown out of 100:

  • Score = sum of (weight × rating) ÷ sum of (weight × 5), for the criteria you rated.
  • Margin = (selling price − landed cost) ÷ selling price. If you leave the margin rating on "Auto", it's turned into a rating with fixed bands: 60% or more scores 5, 45% scores 4, 30% scores 3, 15% scores 2 and anything lower scores 1. The bands are our assumption and are labeled in the results.
  • A criterion you leave blank is left out of that idea's score, and the results say which ones are missing.
  • A rating of 1 on a criterion weighted 4 or 5 is flagged as a possible dealbreaker.

Assumptions, limits and privacy

  • The scorecard doesn't look up search volume, sales or competitors. Every rating comes from you, so base them on research you trust.
  • Margin here is before fees, shipping, returns and marketing. Check the full picture with the Profit Margin Calculator.
  • A high score is a reason to test a product with a small order, not a guarantee that it will sell.

Everything you enter or open stays in your browser and isn't uploaded to Ecom Outpost. Nothing is saved unless you choose "Save on this device", which keeps your inputs but never a file you opened. Saved only in this browser. Not synced to an account. Clearing browser data may remove saved results.

Next steps

See all free tools · Free SEO tools