Every few weeks someone asks me which print on demand service they should use, and every time I want to answer with a question: what's the problem you're trying to solve? The services overlap a lot, and the differences that matter are small and specific to you.
So this isn't a ranking. It's a shortlist, sorted by problem, plus a few thoughts on what happens after you pick. If you've already got a store and want more people to find it, Ecom Outpost has a page for store owners, but that comes later. First, the supplier.
If you want a different cut of this same decision, I wrote about how I'd choose one without calling any of them the best, and about growing a print on demand store when everyone sells the same blank tee. This one is the shorter, more practical list.
Start with the shortlist Shopify already gives you
Shopify's help center has a list of recommended print on demand apps, and it names Gelato and Printful among them. It also says the list isn't exhaustive and that you should browse the app store for more. That's a fair warning. A list of two is a starting point, not a verdict.
I'd add Printify to the pile, because it comes up constantly and because it works a little differently. Here's how I'd describe the three using nothing but what each one says about itself.
Printful is a print on demand and fulfillment service that prints, packs and ships custom products for your store's orders. On its Shopify app page, the product categories include clothing and accessories, bags and luggage, home and garden, baby products, and sports products. That tells you the range is wide. It doesn't tell you the quality is right for your product, which you'll have to find out yourself.
Gelato routes orders to production partners in many countries so products can be printed closer to the customer. It integrates with Shopify. If your customers are spread across several countries, that design is the part to think about.
Printify connects your store with a network of third-party print providers, who print and ship custom products as orders come in. The word that matters there is network. You're choosing among providers, not one factory.
That's it. Three services, three slightly different shapes. Now the question is which shape fits your store.
List your storeon Ecom Outpost
Sort by where your customers live
This is the first filter I'd use, and it's the one people skip because they're staring at product catalogs.
If most of your orders will ship inside one country, shipping distance is a smaller worry. If you expect orders from several countries, then where the thing gets printed starts to matter, because a package that crosses an ocean takes longer and tests the customer's patience. That's the logic behind printing closer to the buyer, and it's worth testing against the countries you actually sell to.
A comparison page that Printify published on Gelato vs Printful covers pricing, print quality and shipping, and some of its delivery ranges are wide. One international window on the page runs from 1 to 20 business days. I can't tell you which service that belongs to from the excerpt I have, and I'd rather say so than guess. But notice the width of that range. A spread like that is the kind of thing you should look at on the actual pages before you promise a delivery date on your own site.
One more thing about that page: it's published by Printify, which is one of the three services being compared. That doesn't make it wrong. It means I'd read it as one input and check the claims against each service's own pages.
Sort by what you're printing
Not every service handles every product equally, and "print on demand" covers a huge range, from shirts to bags to things for the home.
Before you compare anything else, write down the three or four products you'd launch with. Then check whether each service offers them, in the sizes and colors your design needs. This sounds obvious. It's also where a lot of people get a week into setup and find the product they pictured isn't quite there.
I'd also look at the product the way a shopper will. Product presentation is part of the business, not decoration. While building my stores I've had to make plain, practical calls about descriptions, images, packaging and brand identity, and I learned that putting a product on a site is the smallest part of it. The page has to say what the brand offers and help someone understand what they're buying. A supplier that gives you a good base product but leaves you stuck on how to present it is only half a solution, so pay attention to what sits around the product: mockup tools, branding options, what goes in the package.
Sort by how much the box matters to you
Some stores can live with a plain shipment. Others sell on feel, and for those, an unbranded package is a missed chance to look like a real brand.
If packaging and labels matter to you, check what each service offers on branded inserts, labels and packaging, and be specific about it. Don't assume. There are print on demand apps built with custom branding in mind, and a few of them are worth a look if the unboxing is part of your pitch. I'd rather you ask each service a direct question than trust a feature list.
The market is huge, and that shouldn't drive your decision
You'll see big numbers in articles on this topic. One research firm says the global print on demand market was valued at USD 11.38 Billion in 2025, expected to hit USD 61.79 Billion at a CAGR of 20.06% during 2026-2034. Sounds like a gold rush.
Here's my take: it doesn't help you pick a supplier, and it doesn't tell you whether your store will work. Another source puts it plainly: each firm measures vendor revenue under its own scope, so the totals are not interchangeable. Big market numbers tell you lots of people are selling print on demand products. They don't tell you any of them are selling yours. More sellers means more of the same blank tee, which is a competition problem, not an opportunity.
Picking a supplier is the easy part
Here's what I actually think. Choosing between three reasonable services is a decision you can reverse. It's a few hours of setup, a few sample orders, a look at the results. What you can't reverse is the months you spend with a store nobody finds.
I've learned that launching an online store doesn't guarantee anyone will see it. I watch Google Search Console impressions and clicks to see whether a store is gaining visibility, and I use that to judge whether the SEO is progressing, not how nice the site looks or how many pages it has. Organic traffic takes patience.
I also keep the stages separate. A store can show up in search and attract few visitors, and visitors don't always become customers. So I look at impressions, clicks and orders as three different numbers, then decide what to fix. If you have a print on demand store with plenty of impressions and no clicks, the supplier isn't your problem. Your titles and images probably are.
And I try not to keep pouring money into an idea just because I like it. On my niche stores I watch impressions, clicks and sales for signs of traction, and I let those numbers argue with my enthusiasm. A print on demand store is cheap to start, which makes it easy to start five and nurture none. Pick one design direction, give it some time, and read the numbers honestly.
Where does a listing fit? On Ecom Outpost, shoppers find stores and products and click through to buy on the store's own website, so you keep your checkout and your customers. Stores connect through the Ecom Outpost app for Shopify, and billing goes through Shopify with no long-term contract. Every plan includes a store profile and store search. Your products only appear in search and departments on a plan that includes product discovery, and plans with analytics show how many shoppers viewed and clicked your listings. I can't promise traffic, rankings or sales from any of it, and neither should anyone else. It's one more surface, and the numbers will tell you whether it earns its place. If you want to look, the merchants page explains how it works.
How I'd decide this week
Here's the order I'd go in.
- Write down the first three or four products you'd sell and where your customers live.
- Check whether Printful, Gelato and Printify each offer those products, and read each service's own pages on shipping.
- Decide how much your packaging matters. If it matters a lot, ask direct questions about branding options.
- Order samples before you list anything. Judge them the way a shopper would.
- Launch small, then watch impressions, clicks and orders as separate numbers.
That's the whole method. It's not clever, and it won't hold up to a tidy chart. But it keeps the supplier choice in its place: an important decision, not the one that makes or breaks the store.



